Miss Windsor’s Pumpkin Puree (for Pumpkin Pie)

Miss Windsor's recipe for pumpkin puree for pumpkin pie!
Image text

Hello, darlings!

Okey dokey – let’s crack on and make some pumpkin puree from scratch! Perfect for pumpkin pie or as a tasty, seasonal, healthful alternative to our beloved starch ladened mashed potato.

​I say, if you’re keen on recreating the latter, then Miss Windsor recommends to “jazz” it up a smitch with a dollop of butter, followed by a sprinkling of sea salt and cracked black pepper – How spiffing! 

Miss Windsor: recipe for pumpkin puree for pumpkin pie!
Photo by Miss Windsor – baked pumpkin!

Be warned: I’m a lady of very little patience, and will not tolerate cheating or bone idleness! Therefore, what a sheer disappointment it would turn out to be if you’d succumbed to the convenience of “readymade” pumpkin puree from a can – darlings, take heed! ​

​But as you’re here, you’re permitted to breathe a sigh of relief, as presumably, you wish to make pumpkin puree the old-fashioned way – especially if you plan on whipping up one of those good old American classics of pumpkin pie.

Miss Windsor's recipe for pumpkin puree - for pumpkin pie!
Photo by Miss Windsor – pumpkin puree

Darlings, I must say, before you toddle off to your kitchen, according to Fannie Merritt Farmer’s recipe for pumpkin pie which I discovered in my 1909 edition of The Boston-School Cook Book, our dearest Fannie recommends using steamed and strained pumpkin. However, and for no particular reason at all, I prefer to use baked pumpkin instead.

Miss Windsor's Delectables - Fannie Farmer's Pumpkin Pie - recipe from The Boston Cooking-School Cookery Book
Fannie Farmer’s Old-Fashioned Pumpkin Pie!

Enjoy!

Miss Windsor x

Miss Windsor’s Pumpkin Puree ​(for Pumpkin Pie & Savoury Dishes)

Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 1 hour

Ingredients

  • one medium pumpkin (of the edible kind!)
  • olive oil

Instructions

  1. First off, please thoroughly wash your grubby little ‘paws’ – much obliged!

  2. Preheat your oven to 190*C / 170*C Fan / 375*F / gas mark 5.

  3. With a sharp knife carefully cut the pumpkin in half and remove the stem.

  4. Then with a large spoon and a firm grip, scrape out the insides and seeds. Make sure you do a good job now and remove every last seed!

  5. Line your baking tray with foil, and gently lay down the pumpkin halves. Then merrily rub olive oil over both halves.

  6. Place on the middle shelf of your oven and bake for 1 hour – until fork tender.

  7. When your pumpkin halves are ready, carefully remove the tray from the oven.

  8. Now, carefully scrape out the succulent flesh from the skins. Darlings, if you find the flesh a tad bit watery, just drain off the excess.

  9. Using a potato masher and some ‘elbow grease’ commence mashing! Mash until it resembles a puree like consistency. Use a sieve to drain off any excess water.

  10. Congratulations you’ve successfully made Miss Windsor's Pumpkin Puree from scratch!

Leave a Reply